This was our first time in the Keys, and after trying to decide if we should move around a couple of times, I just booked this place for the whole week. Couldn't have been better. The apartment was absolutely spotless, tastefully decorated, and very comfortable. We enjoyed the little beach (others have said it's too small - I mean, it's 25 steps away! what do you want!), the pool, and walking over to Sunset Park for sunset. Easy trips to Sombrero Beach, Bahia Honda, Key West, and Islamorada - and also a couple days of not leaving the property at all. Slept so well I asked about the mattress - better than ours at home!
Heed others' reviews about bringing quarters - $2 to wash, $2 to dry. Then you don't have to waste time chasing down quarters (though you can get them from the office during business hours).