Find & compare romantic hotels in Eureka, CA from $131

"I was a little concerned after reading some of the reviews, but our stay here was perfect. We opted for a room with a jetted tub which was great after two long days of hiking (though one person complained that the jets weren't powerful enough.) The room was clean and the grounds were well maintained. Sound was not an issue, but the door doesn't block sound that well so it's possible to hear people coming and going from their rooms within the courtyard quite easily. On the other hand, we were serenaded by the frogs in the koi pond every night. The outdoor hot tub was closed for maintenance, but the indoor hot tub was open. Pool closes at 9pm so by the time we were at our room each night, it was already closed, but that's why we got the room with the tub. The area around the hotel and the parking lot did not seem unsafe in any way. I rarely saw anyone who wasn't a hotel guest when I looked out the window. Our room had a sliding door that looked out onto the adjacent street and it wasn't an issue. Oh, one minor complaint - the TV had motion smoothing enabled on every channel so all the movies looked like soap operas. TV was basically unwatchable. Should be disabled but there's no way to adjust the menu settings. "

"The Carter House is gorgeous, the room is very well maintained and comfortable. The room and facility is also very clean. The staff are exceptionally friendly and go above and beyond for each of their guests. This was our second stay and will be where we stay every time we visit Eureka. We highly recommend this above anything else in Eureka."

"Could hear people in the other room snoring. Disappointedly not haunted "